What Is Pay-For-Performance SEO? Pros And Cons


Thanks for subscribing!

You’ve most likely seen advertisements like “Rank #1 in SERPs tremendous quick and low-cost through the use of our efficient Web optimization ways. Assured!” 

Tempting however suspicious, isn’t it? That is sometimes how pay-for-performance Web optimization companies market their providers.   

These companies sweet-talk about how they solely cost shoppers after reaching what the shopper desires. But when it sounds too good to be true, it normally is. Let’s have a look at the professionals and cons of results-based Web optimization—as a result of conscious means armed. 

Pay-per-performance Web optimization: what sort of beast is it?

There are completely different pricing fashions in Web optimization, together with:

  • Month-to-month retainer, which is the month-to-month charge for the Web optimization package deal or separate providers;
  • Mission-based charge, i.e., a predetermined price of Web optimization providers for the undertaking;
  • Hourly charges, which means that the shopper pays for Web optimization providers on an hour-by-hour foundation.

However there’s additionally yet another pricing kind to think about—a performance-based Web optimization program.

Pay-for-performance Web optimization (PFP) is a mannequin the place the shopper solely pays if the company fulfills their request. It may be rating positions, site visitors, leads, or the rest. You may negotiate nearly something Web optimization-related with pay-for-performance Web optimization firms. 

Pay-on-results Web optimization pricing is determined by your required end result. Two primary metrics to look out for embrace site visitors and key phrase rankings. Right here’s what you may count on after doing a little market analysis:

  • If you wish to rank #1-2 for a specific key phrase, be able to pay $500-$550 once you get the consequence. Decrease positions are barely cheaper: #3-4 will price you $400-$450, and #5-6 will price about $300-$350.
  • The price of rising each day site visitors to your web site is determined by what number of guests you need. In order for you 500 or extra shoppers, count on to pay a minimum of $1,000. If you happen to’re capturing for 100 or extra visits, the value could begin at $650.

Let’s see how issues stand with different pricing fashions:

  • Month-to-month. Will be $1100 or extra relying on the scope of offered providers.
  • Mission-based. Will be $1500 or greater relying n the undertaking’s complexity.
  • Hourly. Usually ranges from $150-$350 per hour.

It’s no marvel PFP continues to be common. At first look, month-to-month, project-based, and hourly fashions seem greater in worth. However appears to be like might be deceiving.

In concept, pay-for-performance Web optimization ought to work identical to conventional fashions. The company ought to analyze your area of interest and rivals, analysis key phrases, audit the positioning, analyze your backlink profile, carry out on-page checks, and fulfill the enhancements you requested for.


Rating your web site in 2 minutes.

Enter any web site URL to get an in depth report on tech points and instructed options.

This mannequin may work if the company utilizing it’s well-renowned, makes use of sound Web optimization ways, they usually’re dedicated to your success.

(Spoiler: this normally isn’t the case.)

Professionals of pay-for-performance Web optimization

There are two issues many purchasers don’t like to listen to when coping with Web optimization service suppliers: 

  1. Web optimization takes time
  2. There’s no 100% assure to get high outcomes 

Why would anybody spend their precious sources on an company that may’t even assure the outcomes they need, proper? It’s not that straightforward, however pay-for-performance Web optimization companies would have you ever consider it’s. These companies promise fast outcomes with none dangers.

However let’s take a more in-depth have a look at how PFP Web optimization firms deal with their shoppers’ ache factors.

  • Response to the “Web optimization takes time” assertion 

Everyone knows that point is cash. If Web optimization wants time to work, it additionally wants cash to gas it. If it takes rather a lot of time, then the investments enhance. Within the pay-for-performance Web optimization mannequin, the emphasis shifts from time to outcomes. 

Businesses vouching for pay-on-results Web optimization say that their shoppers solely pay for particular outcomes and never for the time the corporate spends engaged on their undertaking. 

This creates the phantasm of saving cash.

Pay-for-performance Web optimization firms additionally argue towards Web optimization being a long-term course of. They promise to “enhance site visitors in three weeks” or “get extra leads in only one month,” and so on. This method creates a misleading impression of fast outcomes that’s, nevertheless, not at all times correlated with high quality. 

  • Response to the “there’s no 100% assure to get high outcomes” assertion 

Every little thing is tremendous easy right here. If you happen to get no outcomes, you don’t pay. This fashion, pay-on-results Web optimization consultants current their method as risk-free. That is an attractive perk for web site house owners.

Pay-for-results Web optimization companies additionally assure to their shoppers that they are going to obtain the agreed-upon outcomes, typically inside unrealistically set deadlines.

Utilizing the magic phrase “assure” is a advertising trick. Businesses that use this phrase are attempting to get you to consider that they’re on the identical aspect as you. They are saying they wish to ship the outcomes you want ASAP.

However the depth of this aim is completely different for either side. You wish to take your web site to the subsequent stage and enhance profitability in the long term. The PFP company desires to receives a commission for its providers as quickly as potential.

The “advantages” provided could appear convincing, however actions converse louder than phrases. Attempt to determine what hides behind these lovely phrases and loud guarantees. Not all pay-for-Web optimization-results firms are dishonest, however you must do a ton of analysis earlier than placing your religion in a single.

Cons of pay-for-performance Web optimization

Since pay-on-result Web optimization companies normally wish to receives a commission ASAP, they might resort to some shady ways that carry on some short-term enhancements. Contemplate the possible disadvantages of those ways.

PFP SEO isn't that perfect

The result’s a blurry idea

Efficiency-based Web optimization applications are nearly fully results-driven. And that’s the lure. 

A pay-on-results Web optimization company would possibly assist you obtain your surface-level targets. They could drive “vital metrics” like site visitors to your web site however fail to think about web page expertise. PFP companies received’t discover efficient methods to enhance your UX and enhance your conversion charge. You received’t be capable of convert the site visitors PFPs curate for you into leads as a result of guests received’t keep lengthy sufficient so that you can go away an impression on them. 

It’s additionally debatable how “vital” any Web optimization metric is to your organization and your targets as a result of there are different components to think about. Pay-for-performance Web optimization firms would possibly attempt to persuade you that site visitors and key phrases are all you must succeed.  However different success metrics are price monitoring and reporting since you’ll obtain a superb long-term consequence when all key metrics are pumped progressively and collectively.

Unproductive key phrase focusing on

Pay-for-performance Web optimization companies could select easy-to-target key phrases as an alternative of ones that match your advertising targets. These companies sometimes use very particular medium and long-tail key phrases with low search quantity. The search quantity metric reveals what number of occasions a month individuals seek for your goal key phrase. 


Enter a search time period and discover untapped key phrase alternatives to make your web site extra seen in search.

This doesn’t imply that long-tail key phrases shouldn’t ever be used, however there’s a time and a spot for all the things. 

Working with key phrases is not only inserting a number of phrases and phrases into the content material and ready for outcomes to return. Making an attempt to optimize your content material for serps with out offering a precious expertise to your readers received’t take you very far both. Your content material ought to at all times fulfill your readers’ finish targets (intents). If you happen to present personable, easy-to-read, and helpful content material, your readers will reward you. They’ll purchase your product and are available again for extra of your content material.

Constructing matter relevance and creating high quality content material are long-term methods that work. However these methods are too labor-intensive and time-consuming for pay-for-performance Web optimization firms that wish to ship outcomes quick and receives a commission. 

Brief-term technique

There’s nothing short-term about Web optimization. It takes time and dedication to see outcomes. You have to be cautious of any company that guarantees outcomes in a single day—even when they ship. It’s possible that any outcomes you see from the pay-per-results mannequin will probably be fleeting at greatest. 

The rewards for utilizing time-consuming however moral optimization practices as an alternative are long-lasting.

The short-termness of pay-for-performance Web optimization may even harm your enterprise in the long term. However that’s the worth you need to pay for relying solely on the “experience” of PFP companies. They too typically use not-so-clean strategies to realize the short outcomes they promise.

Black-hat Web optimization ways

Some pay-on-results Web optimization firms use black-hat strategies. These are unethical ways that may result in penalization by the search engine. 

Some well-known black-hat strategies embrace:

  • Cloaking, i.e., displaying completely different content material to customers and serps;
  • Key phrase stuffing, i.e., loading your content material with key phrases to govern the web page’s rating;
  • Paid backlinks, i.e., buying and promoting hyperlinks only for the sake of a hyperlink;
  • Plagiarized content material, i.e., duplicate content material or utilizing another person’s content material as your individual;
  • Personal Weblog Networks, i.e., a gaggle of internet sites used completely for constructing hyperlinks.
Inevitable penalization

Even when these ways “work,” serps are good sufficient to detect them. Engines like google received’t hesitate to penalize you for utilizing them both. This can trigger your web site’s rankings to plummet or disappear from the search outcomes altogether. You may repair this, however it’s going to take time. It’s higher to not get caught up on this mess within the first place as a result of time means site visitors.

Lack of transparency

Web optimization companies that use commonplace cost fashions take the time to place themselves in your footwear. They assist you outline your low-level Web optimization targets, high-level enterprise aims, and appropriate methods to realize them by way of optimization for serps. They present you the way effectively their technique is working by offering progress reviews. PFP Web optimization companies received’t do that as a result of they’re extra all for getting paid.

Pay-for-performance Web optimization firms additionally use imprecise pricing insurance policies. Good luck sifting by way of a maze of the unclear pricing info. You could find yourself paying greater than you initially anticipated and much more than with conventional Web optimization pricing fashions. 

No preliminary funding = no sources to make sure high quality

Content material high quality is the secret with regards to Web optimization success. Your content material needs to be distinctive, contemporary, and precious to your shopper. This could take a variety of time if you happen to’re doing it your self. If you happen to’re searching for good writers, you get what you pay for. Low-cost labor sometimes means low-cost outcomes.

It’s a superb follow to allocate 25-30% of your advertising funds to content material advertising. However the US Small Enterprise Administration recommends that firms that make lower than $5 million a 12 months in gross sales spend 7 to eight% of their gross revenue on advertising. However that’s nonetheless some huge cash.

It doesn’t matter how assured pay-on-results Web optimization companies are about their pricing mannequin. Requiring no preliminary funding is dangerous enterprise. In order for you high quality content material, it’s important to do your analysis after which put money into the corporate you select. Paying the company from the beginning is like giving them a handshake. You perceive that you just’re getting what you pay for, and the company understands that they’ve an obligation to offer the providers promised. In any other case, who is aware of how your content material is being produced or who is producing it. 

Is performance-based Web optimization at all times unhealthy?

Not at all times.

It can be a viable possibility for web sites which can be authoritative of their area of interest. Perhaps your common web site not too long ago launched a brand new service or product, and you must outsource your manpower to advertise. Watch out although. Pay-for-performance Web optimization can solely be an extra method to advertise that particular a part of your web site. 

It’s human nature to search for simpler methods to realize targets, however this doesn’t at all times work for Web optimization. Boosting site visitors to your web site and enhancing rankings, amongst different metrics, can take up a variety of time and sources since Web optimization is a posh, ongoing, and data-driven course of that considers a holistic method. However that’s your ticket to rising income.

If you happen to resolve to work with a pay-on-results Web optimization company, keep cautious and see how clear the company is. It’d work out if you happen to can talk about intimately your targets, ways, reporting, and pricing. 

Tricks to keep away from Web optimization scams

Good Web optimization improves your web site and will increase the variety of prospects and conversions. Many firms working within the Web optimization market supply each conventional and pay-for-performance Web optimization plans. There are some respected ones, however there are additionally a lot of scammers. Be careful for companies promising fast optimization. That’s the largest pink flag. Most companies who make this promise are attempting to “pump out” cash from gullible prospects.

Listed here are some tips about how to decide on a contractor so that you don’t run right into a scammer:

  1. Test the corporate’s background

Learn case research and evaluations in regards to the firm on third-party sources. You too can contact earlier shoppers to get firsthand info.

  1. Keep away from firms that assure outcomes

There are not any ensures in Web optimization as a result of there are a lot of variables. Every market holds distinctive challenges, patrons have distinct wants, algorithms have guidelines that may be up to date, and so on. And the phrase “assure” is only a advertising ploy to draw extra Web optimization shoppers.

  1. Test your potential contractor’s web site efficiency

If their web site is poorly optimized, then use that as a benchmark for what you may count on your web site to appear like.

  1. Speak to the corporate consultant

The corporate needs to be clear concerning processes, ways, reporting, and pricing fashions. Speak to the corporate heads and ask all of the questions you may have.

Use PFP SEO wisely

And yet another tip: examine Web optimization. It will likely be simpler so that you can scope out shady companies if you happen to perceive the fundamentals of Web optimization.


Do you keep in mind that advert from the article intro?

Right here’s the up to date model:

“Rank #1 in SERPs tremendous quick, however quick time period, and low-cost, however you could find yourself paying greater than you anticipated through the use of our efficient, however not at all times moral, Web optimization ways, which can get your web site penalized. Assured, however not for positive!” 

That is extra like the reality.

Web optimization paid-on outcomes would possibly appear like an all-inclusive resolution to your Web optimization considerations, however it isn’t. De facto, it may well do extra hurt than good and would possibly even cost you a heftier worth than conventional Web optimization.

Don’t search for fast outcomes and 100% ensures if you happen to’re attempting to save cash. Search for a clear firm with a clear portfolio. An moral, affected person, and resilient Web optimization firm realizes that the highway to Web optimization success isn’t a dash. It’s a marathon.


Scroll to Top